6

I'm not sure it has been raised before as this is not a stack I visit. I've seen this ad on another stack:

Ad seen on another stack

My eyes started to bleed.

Ok, not that much, but since my vision could be better, I really had trouble reading what's on there. So I put on my glasses and have the same issue.

Perhaps the colour of the font should be changed to white, with a blue drop shadow instead. Anyways, I'm not really there to suggest anything, I'm no designer.. It's just that now it's really hard to read.

  • We just got the ad... like... today... we've been talking about it in chat, actually... it's pretty horrid. – Catija Sep 8 '15 at 20:14
  • Ah, ok, well I guess it still requires some fine tuning then! – user25752 Sep 8 '15 at 20:18
  • This is highly related to this similar bug-report on the main meta about Chemistry's ads. But thanks for adding it here, too. – Napoleon Wilson Sep 8 '15 at 20:21
  • Ha, yeah, well I thought pointing this out here would be the proper way. I see there is a link to here there so I guess it'll be taken care of! Np! – user25752 Sep 8 '15 at 20:28
  • 2
    Related issues with the background image of the ad: meta.movies.stackexchange.com/q/1917/49. – Napoleon Wilson Sep 8 '15 at 20:51
  • I made a new update to my answer after they fixed the font/shadow. Seems solved now. – Napoleon Wilson Sep 22 '15 at 9:14
3

Indeed. This seems to be a general problem with all the sites that recently got the HNQ ads (after having been forgotten previously) and seems to be due to the use of some kind of default font color instead of font colors tailored to the site's actual color palette. It is already adressed in this related question for Chemistry.SE's ad.

The font colors should rather be oriented towards our site's own color palette (enter image description here) as originally presented (maybe using the light color for the font and the dark color for the shadow or the other way around, upto the designers' discretion). Along with similar issues about the actual background image, as adressed in this related bug report, a possible solution to those problems might look similar to this (only a possiblity):

enter image description here


UDPATE 2015-09-15: The font color seems to have been fixed to some degree into plain white, which makes it less agressively fighting with the background (that has been fixed, too) and improves readability.

enter image description here

However, I'd still not consider this solved yet, since the current plain white text and the very bold and blurry font is still quite hard on the eyes. But as a comment on the respective main meta version of this question points out, this might already by fixed by removing the white drop shadow that still seems to be there on the white text.


UDPATE 2015-09-22: So, the problems with the thick font/white drop shadow seem to have been solved now, too. With those changes I'd consider all the problems with our HNQ ad solved now:

enter image description here

  • Even with the fixes, that's still butt ugly :( – cde Sep 9 '15 at 18:48
  • 2
    @cde But at least it fits to the site's design. If you like that in the first place is a different question, I guess. – Napoleon Wilson Sep 9 '15 at 19:56

You must log in to answer this question.