5

At the moment the tag is ambiguous, as the tag wiki states itself:

Generally, indicates the presence of extra-terrestrial beings in a film or television project. Can also specifically refer to the second of the Alien movie series.

I think one tag should not refer to two completely different things, because that way it becomes completely useless as a filter.

In this scenario, it might still work if I am interested in questions about aliens in general, because the second Alien movie happens to fall into that category. If I however want to specifically find questions about the movie Aliens by James Cameron, I have to dig through all the noise of movies having aliens in them.

Thoughts?

11

My suggestion would be to drop the general meaning completely, since it's rubbish. In my opinion creating tags for each and every general topic a movie could be about is not a good idea. Therefore should be used for the specific movie Aliens and nothing else. (I have to admit that I think to remember having already enforced this policy on my own behalf in the past, without opening a meta discussion for it. Forgive me if this wasn't in the spirit of the overall community.)


But whatever will be decided on the neccessity of a general alien topic-tag (which is the more general and more important question buried within this question), the tag named should still be used for the specific movie instead of naming it differently. Since the general tag would have a larger range of possible names, the movie, which only has a single unique name, should therefore have prevalence over the general topic (another possibility would be , but this policy should only be used for duplicate movie titles).

  • 1
    agreed. using "aliens" for any movie that has aliens is not a good idea, it should only be used for questions concerning the movie "Aliens." – DForck42 May 12 '13 at 22:29
  • I think your opinion should be implemented. – Ankit Sharma May 13 '13 at 7:52
  • Fair enough, that wouldve been my alternative solution anyway. :) – magnattic May 13 '13 at 8:13
  • 1
    I can however think of a few rare cases where a tag for extra-terrestrials in movies would have a valid use case. (for example how their portray has changed over the years etc.) But you are right that we should move the discussion of general topic tags to another meta question. – magnattic May 13 '13 at 8:18
  • I'm good with this. – Tablemaker May 13 '13 at 12:15
  • "aliens" to mean "movie that contains aliens" is a terrible tag anyway - it should mean Aliens – user1887 May 13 '13 at 14:19
-4

My suggestion: Split the tag up.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .