Questions tagged [close-reasons]
The close-reasons tag has no usage guidance.
48
questions
3
votes
1
answer
101
views
Community discussion on the new ID question close reason
I have some concerns regarding the introduction of this new close reason for ID questions:
Identification questions must contain sufficient detail to meet the site's quality standards. They should be ...
- 12.5k
6
votes
3
answers
281
views
Please update the site policy to reflect community consensus on allowing identification questions
The community has recently reaffirmed its support for allowing identification (ID) questions on our site. It's time to update our policy and documentation accordingly.
Over a month ago, we had a ...
- 12.5k
17
votes
3
answers
1k
views
What does the community want to do with identification questions?
There have been several topics and discussions about whether "identification questions" should be on-topic or off-topic. Now, anytime such a question is asked, pros and cons come with their ...
- 12.5k
2
votes
2
answers
72
views
Should we allow hypothetical "what if" questions about legal consequences for characters?
There's a question (currently open) on the site: What charges/prison time would Jack Black realistically be looking at by the end of School of Rock?
This essentially asks for speculation on a ...
- 12.5k
4
votes
2
answers
38
views
The close vote reason isn't working properly?
The question about Dune part III has been closed and reopened.
It's not whether either reasons are good or bad, it's about what happened after the different actions.
Once the question was reopened, I ...
- 12.5k
0
votes
1
answer
45
views
Requesting the reopening of "What is the painting J. Paul Getty buys in 'All the Money in the World'?"
I think the question, “What is the painting J. Paul Getty buys in 'All the Money in the World'?”, deserves to be reopened. It was closed as off-topic for being a trivia question, but that’s not a ...
- 12.5k
0
votes
1
answer
83
views
Requesting the reopening of "What type of plant is Léon's plant?"
I would like to request the reopening of the question, “What type of plant is Léon's plant?”, which was closed as off-topic for the reason that “trivia questions are off-topic”. The “trivia” close ...
- 12.5k
-3
votes
1
answer
80
views
Is it on-topic to ask for advice on filmmaking?
A question asking, “How would you credit people who gave writing suggestions but did not actually participate in writing?” was recently left open in the close votes review queue and currently remains ...
- 12.5k
-2
votes
1
answer
86
views
The trivia close reason is no longer valid. Please reopen "What does Marty Jr. yell while crossing the street in BTTF2?"
I would like to request the reopening of the question, What does Marty Jr yell while crossing the street in BTTF2? This question is currently closed as “trivia”. It recently got reopen votes; however, ...
- 12.5k
0
votes
1
answer
181
views
Why did a moderator keep the question about identifying a painting in Eternals closed?
The question, What is the name of this painting displayed on the Domo's wall in Eternals? - which was closed as both "trivia" and "identification" was unilaterally left closed ...
- 12.5k
3
votes
0
answers
30
views
Should we allow questions asking opinions about what type of shot is in a given screenshot?
I came across this question in the Close votes review queue — Open vs closed shot.
Would you classify this image from Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children as an open frame or a closed frame? ...
- 12.5k
17
votes
1
answer
386
views
We're retiring the "trivia" close-reason
First of all, I and the rest of the moderation team want to apologize that the following took a little while and maybe longer than it should have. We discussed this issue early on and were largely in ...
- 59.2k
5
votes
0
answers
89
views
Please update the site's close reasons, site tour, and help center to reflect the community consensus that trivia questions are no longer off-topic [duplicate]
It's been almost 3 months since the meta post, Which trivia questions are on-topic and which are off-topic? (+15/0 votes) was posted. It currently has two answers (+19/-1 and +11/-1 votes) stating ...
- 12.5k
3
votes
2
answers
137
views
Is it on-topic to ask "Mandela effect" questions, where the OP asks if their memory of a movie/TV scene is correct or if the scene actually existed?
I recently reviewed a question in the close votes review queue titled Major Mandela effect in "King Ralph" (1991) (screenshot). The question stated:
I saw it on the internet recently, and a ...
- 12.5k
0
votes
1
answer
106
views
Why does this question have a Historical Lock? It should be reopened
Minutes ago I turned on the TV and saw an item on the wall of the Big Bang Theory apartment. I didn't know what it was, googled it, and was happy to find the exact question asked on Stack Exchange.
...
- 570
4
votes
0
answers
92
views
Please help me improve this question
A question I posted yesterday is currently sitting on two closevotes with two downvotes.
What does this dialogue mean in The Barefoot Contessa (1954)?
I'd very much like to know how to improve this ...
- 422
2
votes
2
answers
150
views
Why are questions about locating or purchasing movie or TV content not allowed?
I find that locating or purchasing movie or TV content is not allowed. Why is that? Searching in Google with this query site:movies.meta.stackexchange.com locating or purchasing movie or TV content ...
- 619
6
votes
1
answer
150
views
Could the question "What movie takes place entirely underwater?" be re-opened?
I've asked this question 2 years ago that I'm trying to re-open now. It is a cinema history question that I really want to know the answer of.
What movie takes place entirely underwater?
I've tried ...
- 823
-4
votes
1
answer
83
views
Should we close questions as "unclear" when they quote dialogue that is not substantiated by evidence?
This recent question asks about how a certain bit of dialog can be explained from the events of the movie, yet that piece of dialogue cannot be found when searching that movie's subtitles.
Shouldn't ...
- 49.4k
-3
votes
1
answer
52
views
Should we close questions about inconsistent plots as duplicate?
I saw a few questions about the Transformers franchise and the movie scripts are full of inconsistencies. Question like "why don't they use lasers in combat when they had lasers to open up a ship ...
- 8,044
7
votes
1
answer
105
views
Question about extended editions of movies
I just saw this question which was posted:
Were any of the The Matrix movies released with extended editions?
I'm curious why this was marked as off-topic? I think the reason given was meant to ...
- 60.2k
9
votes
1
answer
155
views
Should a link to the FAQ post for list of external sites be added to the identification close reason?
The current close reason for identification questions goes like,
Identification questions are off-topic, because they tend to attract low-quality and low-effort posts. The community has decided to ...
A JMod
- 57.9k
8
votes
1
answer
137
views
Can we update the "trivia" close reason to not mention IMDB?
I recently came across a question that was put on hold because it was considered "trivia".
The yellow box under the question showed the close reason as:
Trivia questions are off-topic; we're not ...
- 6,481
3
votes
1
answer
69
views
How did you get the warning popup implemented for identification questions?
How did you get the warning popup implemented for identification questions when user asks a question? We want a similar thing for autograph identification questions on Sports SE.
This meta post doesn'...
- 183
6
votes
1
answer
109
views
What do we do with "Future works" questions?
Future works questions are questions that are about movies or shows that are yet to be released. Many questions about their contents can't be answered as of yet. Or more importantly, the shouldn't be ...
- 5,797
-10
votes
1
answer
140
views
Questions on if or when a movie or show will be released
Are questions asking when or where something will be released on topic?
Are questions asking if something will be released or made on topic?
Multiple questions of the above types have mixed voting (...
- 68.1k
3
votes
0
answers
74
views
Why straight-forward question is getting close votes for being "too broad"?
Why is straight-forward question getting close votes for being "too broad"?
Why did Spielberg use fictional characters (informants Louis and Papa) in Munich
too broad - if your question could be ...
- 964
11
votes
1
answer
169
views
Why is this question getting votes to close?
I don't understand why "Why is Applebee's in so many movies?" is getting votes to close. The question seems squarely within the purview of on-topic questions, e.g. "Questions about a Movie or TV show'...
- 5,898
-1
votes
2
answers
106
views
If this question is off topic, where does it say so?
Very recently, I posted a serious question, which I have been wanting to ask since the general elections in the US had ended.
https://movies.stackexchange.com/questions/65744/has-a-tv-reporter-or-...
- 1,214
10
votes
1
answer
152
views
What exactly counts as a recommendation question here?
One of the off-topic close reasons is:
Recommendation questions asking for movies/TV-shows or resources to locate or watch movie/TV content are off topic. Feel free to ask for people's opinion in ...
- 8,440
13
votes
1
answer
170
views
Change Off-Topic -> Recommendation text
As we have Locating or purchasing Movies or TV content as off-topic in https://movies.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic yet we often get these type of questions, it would be nice if the off-topic close ...
- 68.1k
10
votes
2
answers
241
views
What happens to identification questions that don't have sufficient details, but are answerable nevertheless?
I am referring to this question asked earlier today:
Does anyone know the name of this asian show?
I know that generally these kind of questions tend to get VTC's, because they seldom are ...
- 5,275
5
votes
1
answer
249
views
What topics come under the category of "Current Events"?
We have a custom close reason that reads:
Questions about current events are off-topic because these items are rapidly changing and do not have a definitive answer. For more information, see our ...
- 26.5k
5
votes
2
answers
390
views
How to properly close recommendation questions?
As of recent there were quite a few questions asking for movie recommendations, which are currently off-topic on this site, and those questions arise now and then and are usually closed quite fast and ...
- 59.2k
6
votes
1
answer
100
views
Let's make the ID-close reason text & explanation more useful
We have, as a community, decided to consider commercials and music videos as "off topic" for the purpose of identify questions.
What identify-this questions should be kept/deleted?
ID-This-...
- 26.5k
6
votes
1
answer
116
views
Handling duplicates that aren't exactly duplicates
Just came across this vote to close:
A movie about a lorry in space transporting robots?
Now, as pointed out by Walt, the answers are duplicate. However, the questions are different, and unless you ...
- 60.2k
4
votes
0
answers
69
views
How should we handle "What if" questions?
Questions asking "what if" are off-topic as per the Help-Center:
To prevent your question from being flagged and possibly removed, avoid asking subjective questions where …
...
you are ...
- 4,769
6
votes
1
answer
217
views
What is the difference between close-voting detail-lacking ID questions and deleting inactive ones?
There has been quite some confusion recently as to what to do with old inactive ID-questions and what the difference is between close-voting for "not enough detail" and deleting for inactivity, ...
- 59.2k
4
votes
1
answer
51
views
How to deal with questions with a clearly wrong premise?
In this question Why does Tom Hanks' character never open up the last package? the premise is clearly wrong. He does open every package except one. How to deal with such a question? Editing it ...
- 2,941
2
votes
2
answers
80
views
Should Plot Inconsistency tags have a time limit?
I'm aware from this previous question: Are questions about specific plot details on topic? that discussions on specific plot details in a movie are acceptable.
I also know from this highly useful ...
- 51.4k
4
votes
0
answers
84
views
Remove 'Too localized' as a valid close question reason
In response to IandotKelly's suggestion that I quit whining and start being pro-active about the pedantry on this site (my words, not his by the way!), I'd like to request that we disregard the ...
- 38.6k
1
vote
3
answers
279
views
Breaking Bad question wrongly "put on hold" for being a list question (no set rule against lists, however)
This question was placed on hold. As you can see from the comments, I fiercely defended it and made the suggested changes, and yet certain users still claimed it was unsuitable. Please could someone ...
- 38.6k
9
votes
2
answers
109
views
Quest to reopen the question about Batman and fear of death
There is fairly constant complaining on meta about the quality of questions and the overabundance of identity questions. There are also consistent concerns about attracting new users.
So a new user ...
- 17.3k
2
votes
1
answer
78
views
Why was this identify-this-actor question closed as not constructive?
Here's the question.
I could understand this being closed as off-topic, since it is trivia, or as too localized, since it is extremely specific. But the "not constructive" rubric says "We expect ...
- 6,409
1
vote
2
answers
56
views
What's wrong with this question?
I'm trying to find out what's wrong with this question. But i couldn't.
https://movies.stackexchange.com/questions/2448/what-is-the-significance-and-history-of-using-swear-in-movies
I don't think ...
- 20.4k
10
votes
1
answer
170
views
Should we close older Identify questions?
We have about 25% of our unanswered questions belonging to identify-this-movie, 9 of which were asked over 2 months ago (before March).
I want to close them purely for the fact that they have been ...
- 34.9k
5
votes
1
answer
104
views
Need an appropriate way to rephrase a soundtrack question
I am curious to see what movies had an original song (or album) composed for the movie itself.
I phrased it this way: What are the top five soundtracks... but it was closed as being off topic ...
- 3,347
5
votes
3
answers
146
views
Should we ask for a 'general reference' close reason?
Looking at this question, What is a "performance capture" animation movie?, I tried to vote to close it, but none of the reasons fit well. I would have liked to vote to close it due to being ...
- 2,239