11
votes
Accepted
Is a question better with a "drive-by diss" than without it?
Yes, these are good edits.
For pretty much exactly the reasons you said: they're not relevant, they don't add anything to the post, and they could be construed as rude. If it's actually relevant to ...
- 8,344
11
votes
Accepted
Should informal sentences (clutter) be allowed in the questions?
Now first of all, I think you are mixing things up a little here. You are adressing too largely different issues in your question.
On the one hand you link to a meta question that concerns the usage ...
- 58.5k
8
votes
Why was this edit approved?
The suggested edit screen is misleading. The edits doesn't show the double spaces that were removed which gets combined with the word immediately following them making it seem like retype words, or ...
- 67.5k
8
votes
Should informal sentences (clutter) be allowed in the questions?
I'm the one who posted the trailer question.
I understand the SE system and I appreciate that Pale Blue Dot was trying to improve the post to follow the rules as they perceived them, for the benefit ...
- 547
5
votes
Accepted
Can't suggest an edit to a tag wiki: "The edit queue is full at the moment" error message is always shown even if the edit review queue is clear
Thanks for the report - this was also raised and addressed on on SE-wide meta
See: It is now impossible to make a suggested edit to a tag-info
- 101
5
votes
Incredibly bad edit including editors questions to op, approved?
The edit actively improved extremely poor grammar. This is good and wanted and it is something we should be encouraging. It takes a lot of time and effort to copy edit a post like that so destroying ...
- 26.4k
3
votes
Incredibly bad edit including editors questions to op, approved?
Because it improved the quality of question without changing the meaning. And it was later improved as well.
I removed some part of it to improve a bit more. Any edit that clarifies the question or ...
A JMod
- 57.6k
1
vote
Accepted
How come this tag [romantic] is not needed on a question when the question is specially about romantic films?
You are right in that the question asks about movies from a specific genre. But there were two problems with this that probably added to a downright rejection of this suggested edit:
The primary ...
- 58.5k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible