iandotkelly
Moderator
  • Member for 10 years, 2 months
  • Last seen this week
Are where can I locate old film / TV show questions valid?
2 votes

Thanks for taking the time to ask a question on Meta, and it would be interesting to see whether people's opinions on this issue has changed. The question is not that far from Where can I buy ? - and ...

View answer
Final TV Decision
2 votes

I personally think that it is making it quite hard if you start saying that TV tie-in movies are off topic. What would Star Trek movies be? Unless you are saying that a major theatrical release ...

View answer
Tags for movies with the same name and remakes?
2 votes

I am still unconvinced that individual movies should be tagged at all, but have been led to believe that little used tags will eventually disappear automatically - so I guess this doesn't matter. So, ...

View answer
Are questions about specific plot details on topic?
2 votes

Like others I don't see the point in not being able to discuss plot points here. Is it more that you have concerns about questions about interpretation. If so, I have some sympathy with your concern,...

View answer
How was the criteria chosen for deleting the identify-X questions?
Accepted answer
1 votes

Criteria needed to be chosen - from keeping nothing to keeping everything. Starting from the Anime and Manga criteria (question score of 4 or more, answer of 3 or more) the moderators discussed the ...

View answer
Let's talk about [sex]
1 votes

I don't necessarily disagree. However put a bit of a perspective on it I think its meant to be used when a question is about sex in movies in general, rather that just another tag alongside a movie ...

View answer
Review not posting in the ribbon?
1 votes

It is appearing for me. And I've confirmed that there were a total of 9 items in my review queue. https://movies.stackexchange.com/review Can you confirm you have items in your queue (as you seem ...

View answer
Rules of Engagement tags
1 votes

The movie should be rules-of-engagement. The tv series should become rules-of-engagement-tv.

View answer
Why are music/score identification questions off-topic?
1 votes

First of all you should note that we're borderline happy as a community about identification questions at all. We have some users (and moderators) who are pretty against them, and a few that like ...

View answer
Improving the English in the Help section
1 votes

Why don't I make this answer a community wiki and allow people to edit it until we're happy with it? ..... Movies & TV Stack Exchange is for Movie & TV enthusiasts and experts alike! If ...

View answer
Can we please split this question?
1 votes

I received the flag, but there are no mod tools to split a question. I left a comment for the person asking the question, with no response. The only course of action open to me is edit to delete the ...

View answer
Adding Screenshots
1 votes

Issues relating to the stackexchange platform in general can be asked on meta.stackoverflow.com. I don't think this is a particular issue to the mechanics site. There are a number of similar error ...

View answer
[movie-rating]: star ratings vs. MPAA/content ratings
1 votes

Gosh, its quite hard to discuss this across several days with several people. I'm going to create this answer and encourage people to comment and edit to arrive at collections of synonymous tags. ...

View answer
TV-Shows tag, should it stay or should it go?
1 votes

It should definitely be bruned :-)

View answer
Is there a way to get rid of deleted posts?
Accepted answer
1 votes

I don't think you can unfortunately. Deleted material is seen by moderators and the person who originated the post.

View answer
Should individual tv or movies have its own tags?
1 votes

Tags do not merely form part of the content of the question - it is meta information that allows the question to be found more easily. The purpose of tags to allow someone to search for questions of ...

View answer
Are questions about cinematography on topic?
1 votes

Personally I would think it would be on topic - it would be interesting to see people's views. I am not sure however how many expert opinions you would have here, but it might be worth a try.

View answer
Could a question of the week be asked on this site?
Accepted answer
1 votes

We must remember that we are a Beta site, so comparing ourselves to a more established non-beta site like Sci-Fi is slightly unfair on us. Sci-Fi had a beta period of around 10 months, and left beta ...

View answer
About [zombies] and [vampires]
0 votes

For the purpose of discussion (in the same way as the sex discussion) to vote for this answer would be to say that we should keep these tags for the purpose of questions that relate to zombie or ...

View answer
Do we have an application of StackExchange or (Movies & TV) on Play store, WMP or on Blackberry world?
0 votes

We are one of many many Stack Exchange sites. As @ChristianRau says - this might be better asked on meta.stackoverflow.com - which is the meta site for the entire StackExchange network. Check there ...

View answer
Questions about reviews and reviewers
-1 votes

I think that a limited number of 'list' questions are acceptable in a SE site. There are a number in Stackoverflow, which have not been deleted because they serve a purpose. I agree that they are ...

View answer
Rules for multiple media using the same name
-2 votes

Surprised no-one else waded in on this one, but I guess its not viewed is a burning problem here. For what it is worth, I think that most recent should get precedence, even if that requires some ...

View answer
Should we create a separate identify-this-short tag?
-3 votes

I do not have a problem with this .... but it will require some effort to re-tag.

View answer
1
3 4 5 6
7